Client Portal
Call (07) 4151 8898 

Taxpayer not a ‘share trader’ despite substantial share trades

In a recent case, a taxpayer undertook significant trades on the stock exchange and made losses, but was still found to be a ‘share investor’, rather than a share trader, meaning she could not deduct her losses against her other income (i.e., her losses were ‘capital losses’ that can only be offset against capital gains).

The Facts

The taxpayer (who otherwise worked as a child care educator and earned approximately $40,000 in wages) started trading shares in July 2010, utilising her (and her husband’s) savings of approximately $60,000 and a margin loan of initially $40,000.

During the 2011 income year, she made:

q      71 purchases to a value of $379,630; and

q      37 sales to a value of $215,019.

She made a loss on her share transactions during the 2011 income year to the order of $20,000, and she was seeking to claim that as a deduction.

The Decision

The Senior Member of the AAT considered the following factors in deciding that the taxpayer was not a share trader.

Factors in favour:

Factors against:

Recent Posts


Subscribe to keep informed!

Sign up for The Money Edge's Money Tips!

First Name
Email Address